Sunday, 21 June 2015

2D or 3D?

I wanted to tackle this at some point, since I am usually quite rude about my CG colleagues. Mostly because it's funny, partly because I feel they are beneath me.

(That last bit is a joke.)

Before starting it's worth noting this is an opinion piece, so if it upsets anyone please take a moment to think about what you're getting angry over. I myself don't much care for either Vegemite or Marmite, but I don't lose sleep over it and I don't yell at people for putting it on their toast. I'll also eat either if I have to or it's free.

My main gripe with CG is simply that I find it cumbersome to use for character animation. That's it. I don't like having to twiddle a good half dozen or so controls to get a strong pose. (There are great CG animators out there, but I'm not one of them.) I also prefer the freedom of 2D, and being able to push things any which way without having to worry about "breaking the rig".

Having said that, I really like 3D stuff. I like having strong volume and  perspective in animation, that's one of the things that drew me in to animation to begin with.

So what I really like is when you get the two together, so here are a few of my faves that marry the two.

Futurama and Belleville Rendezvous both use 3D for hard-surface objects (spaceships, bicycles) and keep the characters in 2D. Hard-surface detail is where CG excels, as it can handle tasks that would be inefficient for a 2D animator. While certainly possible to animate individual bicycle spokes by hand, why waste time on such a chore?



...but this stuff is what really gets me excited. Hybrid techniques, with all the benefits and none of the limitations (Hype)! However right now it's all locked into proprietary software, and it of course introduces new complexities into the workflow. One day maybe...


Disney's Paperman, essentially 3D animation that is then tweaked by 2D artists.


 ...and here's a short history of the tech behind it.

 ,
 And Klaus, which as I understand it is the other way round involving 2D treated to appear 3D. As there is only a teaser so far, the tech behind this one is even less open than Disney's Meander software.


And just in case you think I'm too much in awe of 3D, here's Joe Bowers talking about animating on Tangled. Of course he had to have a 2D guy come in and help him out.

Enjoy your Vegemite.

Your Shrek does not impress me.

Wanted to talk a little about 2D/3D, but first need to put up some 3D!

While I have no formal training in CG, I have played about with it for a while. I made a rig (about four years ago now!) to test out everything I'd learned so far, and try and build a character I could animate with. I wanted something flexible and cartoony that I could stretch about, so it was based on a doodle I did which I have fortunately since lost.

I also wanted to try out a few things I'd seen about the place, including building in parent-space switching for an IK spine, facial expressions based on blend shapes, and also make hand controllers that deformed along with the hand. The hand was a bit tricky as it required a hack of sorts in order to work, however I was happy with the way it turned out.

I also wanted to keep all the deformation controls on the rig. I personally feel it's bad design to use joystick controls, as it splits attention between model and controller. My own preference is to use several switchable control layers to keep the model space clean. If you have a good argument for using joysticks that's fine, but keep them the f*** away from me you filthy animal.

So without further ado, here's an overly long clip of the rig's main features.


Thursday, 18 June 2015

Storyboard week two complete. Had to change a bit, but was storyboards are not my bag so was good to get some feedback. Second revision is about done, moving on to clean up of the rough initial scribbles.

Illustration continues, 12 weeks is actually going to be pretty short for the scope of the exercise, have made some preliminary notes on the setting (locations etc), characters and landscape. Also did a few sketches of trees as I have a couple of landscapes to complete. Started thumb-nailing one of the compositions, so hope to plan out the rest next week.

Sunday, 14 June 2015

Late update, finished work and thinking about sleep.

Finally sketched out a very rough plan for storyboarding. Had some issues with the space being so tight (down a corridor), and given it's the closing sequence I agonised a bit over it and started about 4 different versions before it seemed to be working. In hindsight should have talked with the learning facilitators more, Meh. Sometimes it's okay to do it the hard way. We'll see if it's any good tomorrow...

Also did a bit of research into shotgun wounds. My initial effort involved a lot of red, and a classic bloody hand smear. It didn't feel right though,so I looked up some forensics stuff and have dialed back the gore to pretty much nothing. Would have done some practical tests but don't have access to either a shotgun or a dead pig, so will have to keep this one theoretical.

Need to start planning on the illustration task this coming week. Did a bit of background research on Lovecraft last week, along with picking out a few reference pics. Mostly landscapes and architecture, as it's set in a part of the US I'm not familiar with. Although honestly I'm not really familiar with any of the US.

Tuesday, 9 June 2015

It's been a little busy lately, so I have neglected the blog somewhat.

Finished the style exercise a couple weeks back, it turned out better than I thought it would. Been meaning to do a post-mortem on it but haven't got round to it yet. Maybe later. Also finished the hybrid animal illustration thing, but didn't time manage it well. Wanted to finish it off in Photoshop but left that part too late, which caused some issues as the scans were too crappy to use and I ended up mostly re-drawing things. So it was unfortunately yet another rush job and I missed out on doing a musculature study which was disappointing.

Should I be admitting this? Neither were particularly bad, they just lacked polish.

Here's one of the few frames from the style study which is more or less done. The rest is a bit too sloppy to post up (ended up colouring roughs just to get it done, which I would not recommend at all), plus the continuity errors, and lack of an ending, all of which would be nice to tidy up/finish off.

Moving on... New illustration project has started, 12 weeks but I don't think that's such a long time given the scope. Will endeavour to plan this one out better.

New storyboard project too, 3 weeks this time and it goes back to CG to animate. Still playing around with how to tackle the bit I've been given, so it's moving quite slowly at the moment.