Monday, 27 April 2015

Old School Effects

So I finally got around to watching 101 Dalmatians (and so by extension "the making of"). I'm now going to have to add it to my list of most influential films. Let me tell you why.

It's a great little movie, but as with most Disney fare the story is a little twee for my tastes. (And the RP English is hard for me to take seriously.) However, I've never watched Disney stuff for gripping drama or deep, complex  character depictions. (You'd be an idiot to go in expecting that. They're fun films that are beautifully made, so if you can't appreciate them for what they are then we're done talking.) So how did a film outside my usual sphere of interest catapult itself into such lofty regard?

Well, this time it's for technical reasons. Going on first impressions, one thing that stood out (amongst many) was the vehicle construction. Man they were well drawn, I mean they were really well drawn. They felt solid, even with Cruella driving like a maniac, somehow her car kept its shape brilliantly.

But... They weren't perfect. They seemed to move kinda funny, sometimes they almost felt like they were being pushed around and not driven, the turning circles seemed a little off, that sort of thing. Oh well, it was a pretty minor gripe and I could forgive them that given how good they looked. There was also the sequence where Cruella drove off the road and then pushed through a snow bank, there was something about the style of the snow that didn't seem to quite match the style of the film. Again, a very minor thing and it never really detracted much from the shot. But it did make me wonder.

So how did Disney achieve such convincing machines? And why did some of it seem a little off? As it turns out there was a reason for all that.

The reason was in large part down to the work of Ub Iwerks (I believe one of Walt's original business partners) who started out with Disney, and after some time running his own studio returned in the 1940s. Ub really deserves a post all to himself, but let's just say he had a pretty broad range of talents. Anyway, 101 Dalmatians followed Disney's "Sleeping Beauty", which had not only been expensive to produce but had also failed at the box office. Closing of the Disney animation department was not out of the question. Enter Ub Iwerks, who had been experimenting with Xerox photography techniques. This allowed the studio to photograph the animator's drawings and transfer them directly to the cels, cutting out the entire inking process and allowing 101 Dalmatians to be made for around half the cost of the traditional method.

Now the Xerox process described here was much more like photography than the modern photocopying process we are all familiar with today. The drawings had to be put in front of a camera and essentially photographed before being transferred to the film cels. The stroke of genius was when Ub realised he was taking photographs of lines, and reasoned something like "Why do these lines have to be flat?" What followed was pretty freakin' sweet. Disney built plain white cardboard models, and drew contour lines on them. These physical models could then be filmed directly, and with the correct lighting setup only the lines drawn on the cardboard would transfer to the cels. Essentially Disney had just invented an integrated 2D/3D workflow using practical effects, over 20 years prior to CG animation even existing. This technique could also be extended to include particle-like effects. The scene where Cruella's car drives uphill through a snow bank was made by pulling the cardboard model through a pile of sand.

So any minor quibbles I had were dispelled, given that they were simply a byproduct of the techniques used. The cars do at times look a little bit like they're being pulled along, because they probably were being pulled along. And the "snow" that looked a little different was because it was an actual, physical material that was appearing in a highly stylised world.

Could Disney have done things differently? The alternative option of animating all the vehicles and snow effects by hand would have been orders of magnitude more expensive, would have introduced its own limitations and would likely have at best been of a similar quality. Watch the scene of Cruella's car as it rolls out of control and flies apart, and consider the challenges in handling that sort of complex rotational movement by hand.

So yeah, all of that just blew me away.

Here's a link to the making of where they talk about the practical effects: Making of 101 Dalmatians

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.